The Ninth Sunday after Pentecost
Isaiah 56:1, 6-8; Matthew 15:10-28
"In the fashion world, as in this competition, you're either in or you're out." So says Heidi Klum in one of my favorite TV shows, Project Runway. Now, she has a very fetching German accent, which you will notice I did not even attempt. In the fashion world, Heidi Klum is very definitely in.
There are a lot of things that I love about Project Runway, but the chief thing is that it appeals to my sense of order. They start with a lot of designers, and one by one they are eliminated. Each episode ends with Heidi looking sad, and saying to one hapless contestant, “I’m sorry, that means you are out.” And then another host hugs the loser and sends him or her upstairs to clean up the work room.
Top Chef is a similar show, only it is about cooking instead of fashion design—and the experts aren’t quite as cute as Heidi. But at the end of each episode, a host says, “I’m sorry, please pack your knives and go.”
In both shows, the season starts out in chaos—designers and chefs are everywhere. Whether they are fitting chiffon or chopping onions, the mess flies around. Gradually, some beauty develops—in constructed garments or delicious dishes. And if I cannot taste the food on Top Chef—well, there’s no way I could ever wear the clothes on Project Runway—so it is all about considering and discerning which look or which taste I think I might like the best.
Week by week, a designer and a chef each leave and order begins to emerge, until finally the work room and the kitchen aren’t so terribly messy. The food becomes more complicated and the outfits more elaborate. And for both shows, as the season proceeds, we get to know the designers and the chefs. We begin to make favorites—and to root for them—even if they seem to make an odd choice of fabric, or get caught over-poaching the salmon. And as we get to know them, it gets harder and harder to hear, “I’m sorry, you are out.” Or, “Please pack your knives and go.” Even so, the competition is part of the thrill.
And it makes sense, because who doesn’t like to be in with the in-crowd? And as long as we remember to tune in again next week, we can be with the ones who are flinging the chiffon and chopping the onions. Heidi Klum would never dream of telling us we are out.
The desire to be included is as old as human nature—and right along with it is the urge for order and thrill of competition that makes us exclude one another. It is exactly these contrary impulses that struggle through our lessons this morning.
The prophet Isaiah is telling the people that they can return from their centuries-long exile in Babylon. And when they do, God will welcome them. And not only that, God understands that they have been away for generations—it’s okay that they made relationships while they were in exile. It’s all right if foreigners come with them when they return home. For my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples, says the Lord. You might call the prophet’s attitude “radically welcoming.” And Isaiah knows that this is a new thing for the people to understand about God.
All through the Old Testament, the people busily define themselves as the ones—the only ones—that God loves. And God plays the in-and-out game, too. God finds people difficult to handle and so decides to destroy us by flood. But then, Noah seems righteous, and is saved. God decides that Abraham should be the father of a nation that is under God’s direct sponsorship, and so grants him children even though he is in his 90’s.
Abraham favors Isaac, so his older son Ishmael is—out, clean up your workspace before going out into the desert, please. God favors Isaac’s son Jacob, and he gets the blessing and the birthright instead of his older brother Esau—he cheats by presenting his father with a better tasting and more timely presented stew. In an interesting twist on this in-and-out business, it is Jacob who packs his knives and leaves, but later seems to have been under God’s protection the whole time.
It is this same Jacob whom God names “Israel”—and then there is a grand game of in-and-out among his twelve sons—first the construction of a high-fashion coat of many colors and then all that nastiness about selling Joseph into slavery. And it is Jacob’s sons who become the fathers of the twelve tribes of Israel. By the end of Genesis, they are very definitely in.
All through the Hebrew Scriptures, God is faithful to this one nation of people—the nation who were born of Abraham. The children of Israel believed in God, and made attempts at faithfulness, more or less. But whether they were faithful or not, God never forgot them. The children of Israel were in—in God’s favor, even when they were thrown out into slavery or exile. God knew them. He knew they weren’t perfect, but they had developed a special relationship over the centuries.
And now, millennia into the relationship, Isaiah declares a new thing—that God will welcome everyone to God’s holy mountain—the exiles returning home, the outcasts among the exiles, even the foreigners who follow along—not sure where they are going, but sure that they are looking for welcome.
Five hundred years after Isaiah’s new thing, Jesus is all about the welcome. Drop your nets, he says to Peter and Andrew. I will make you fish for people. And off they go through the Galilean countryside, gathering people, just as Isaiah predicted. The outcasts of Israel were the first to get on board. The sinners, the tax collectors, the prostitutes; widows and orphans; women and children, all fell into Jesus’ wide-open embrace.
Those Pharisees had a harder time of it. They couldn’t seem to get with it. We might think of them as spiritual exiles. They concentrated so hard on God’s justice that they had trouble with the mercy that Isaiah’s prophecy required.
And so Jesus taught them, in a passage so graphic that we will surely remember it—it is not what goes into your body that will make you sick. What goes in comes out just as quickly. No, Jesus said: What makes us sick is how we think about one another, how we treat one another, how we use one another for our own advantage.
Well, you cannot blame the Pharisees for not wanting to be schooled by someone as obviously “out” as Jesus. I mean, really, he hung out with all the people who knew how to clean a workroom and pack up their knives. What could the least and lost of the children of Israel possibly know about God?
Well, how about what Isaiah knew?
Thus says the LORD:
Maintain justice, and do what is right,
for soon my salvation will come,
and my deliverance be revealed.
The ones who followed Jesus understood the yearning of Isaiah. They understood that coming home was more than about where they lived—what they wore—or what they ate. They understood that coming home was about being accepted—that coming home was about being welcomed in.
And so, we have to ask, what were the disciples thinking when they asked Jesus to send the Canaanite woman away? Okay, so she wasn’t a Jew—she was a foreigner. And she was yelling at them—she a woman, was yelling at men—definitely not good manners. But those fishermen and tax collectors weren’t known for their manners.
Why did the disciples find her so disturbing that they begged Jesus to send her away? And come to that, why wasn’t Jesus nice to her? "I was sent only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel." Really? Didn’t Isaiah settle all that centuries ago?
This is one of those times when I really wish I could see Jesus’ face. I want to see a twinkle in his eye—and I want to see him nod his head toward that grumbling group of Pharisees standing a little way off.
We do not know what Jesus was thinking when he said, "It is not fair to take the children's food and throw it to the dogs." But here is what we do know—as bad as her manners were, the Canaanite woman’s story gets told. As loud as she was yelling, as foreign as she was, she didn’t clean up her workspace or pack her knives. She walked right up to Jesus and told him what she needed.
And we know this, too: Jesus recognized her faith. It didn’t matter that her shouting was annoying, or that her daughter’s illness would make them both outcasts, or that she was a foreigner. What mattered to Jesus was her faith. Jesus was faithful, too. And her daughter was healed instantly. And Jesus showed again that even though he understood our human inclination to bring order through exclusion, God calls us to something better.
When the woman came up to Jesus, when she called him by name and begged him for mercy, he could have told her that she was out. He could have turned his back on her. Instead, he engaged her in conversation. We may not like or understand what he said—but we know that there was a power to heal in the connection that he made.
The radical welcome that Isaiah proclaimed and the Canaanite woman claimed for herself and her daughter is the very same welcome that God offers us today. Thus says the Lord, Maintain justice, and do what is right. If we are to heed Isaiah’s proclamation, it begs an important question: just who are the foreigners today? Who are the outcasts?
Maybe it is the child who hates to go to school because the way she looks or the way he speaks draws the attention of bullies. Maybe it is the father who cannot get a doctor’s appointment for his son, because the insurance company doesn’t think the kid is sick enough. Maybe it is the couple that wants to be married, but lives in a state where only some couples have that privilege. I’m guessing you can think of others.
Week by week we come into this holy place—and the truth is, often we know that in one aspect or another of our individual lives, we are the outcasts, we are the foreigners—we are out! We should be cleaning up our work space and packing our knives. But in this place, we claim God’s radical welcome. And more, we are invited to welcome others—any others—outcasts, foreigners, even those who are in with the in-crowd.
All these years later it is up to us to offer the radical welcome of God, to make friends and strangers joyful in God’s house of prayer. When we do, then we will know God’s power to heal and God’s salvation and deliverance will be revealed.
August 14, 2011 Proper 14A
The Episcopal Church of the Atonement
The Rev. Nancy Webb Stroud